Showing posts with label diesel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label diesel. Show all posts

Monday, 28 May 2012

The BMW 640d Vs Human Emotion


This isn't a review. Far from it. In a review I like to be relevant and objective, making like-for-like comparisons and reporting what I find. This is more of a an essay. A screed. A manifesto on what I like in a car. As such; prepare to go absolutely miles off topic.

So,  let's establish that everything Jeremy Clarkson wrote about the BMW 640d in the Sunday Times is pretty well bang-on. Yeah, it's blisteringly quick, quiet, smooth-riding and technologically accomplished. In terms of being a car, save for the fact that it only has two doors, it's one of the more complete cars I've ever driven. Where the current real-world sliding scale of vehicle adequacy is aligned, the 640 scores heavily in the "as good as it needs to be" sector of the dial. It's not perfect; I'm not sure any car is. But it doesn't fall down in any specific area. It's terrific.

And it's about as far from what I want in a car as I can possibly imagine.


Monday, 5 December 2011

Driven #47:- 2011 Mercedes-Benz Viano Edition 125 V6 CDi 3.0


Firstly an issue that applies now every bit as much as it did when I drove the other one. Let's get this straight; Mercedes-Benz are marketing this as basically a grown-up minivan. Well, I'll challenge that and say that a grown-up minivan is, well, a van. You can even buy this vehicle from M-B Commercial Vehicle outlets with a Vito badge attached in place of the Viano one. I say stop the madness and admit that this car is, basically, a Van. And a very good one at that.

Last time I spent time with a Viano it was a fairly prosaic, four cylinder Ambiente model. As a way of carrying groups of people around it did an excellent job, somehow more professional, more businesslike than how a similarly capacious Chrysler Grand Voyager always comes across. I enjoyed driving it, as you probably surmised from my report. But it had me wondering what it would have been like if it had been blessed with a little more power.

Today I found out, with the indecently rapid CDI 3.0.

Saturday, 22 October 2011

Diesel; What Happened To The Backlash? (Part 1)


A colleague the other day told me of comparison event where he drove a crop of current German Big-Three cars, including the Audi A8. It had been of the 4.2 V8 petrol variety, and he said;

“It needed to be a diesel”.

When quizzed about what he meant, he replied that the V8 didn’t have that low-down urge that a diesel car would have enjoyed. And, unknowingly, he’d just exposed a great truth in how we have come to regard diesel cars.

Saturday, 3 September 2011

Driven #38:- Alfa Romeo 159 1.9 JTDm


I seem to be conjuring cars up out of thin air, right now. No sooner have I taken the Giulietta out for a drive (here), and start thinking to myself that it would be nice to have a 159 to compare it to, then suddenly one turns up. So, next week, expect a full report on the McLaren F1.

The Giulietta plays the fashion card, and tries appeals to an image-conscious market. The 159 is the Alfa Romeo for those who want a straight-forward, hard working saloon car, but one which is still an Alfa through and through. Of course, achieving that is no mean feat. 

Thursday, 25 August 2011

Driven #36:- Honda Accord 2.2 GT diesel


Honda are a fantastic brand with a long and distinguished history to be proud of. Fiercely independent, from that first humble Cub motorbike they have developed a huge presence in the automotive and marine sectors, and are growing rapidly in Aerospace.

Their heart, though, has always seemed to be on four wheels. They have many international motorsport championship titles behind them, and occasionally this track genius shines through in products that us lucky punters can buy with actual money. The sublime NSX is revered more now than it ever was in its day, but everything they've ever nailed their Type-R emblem to has possessed a special kind of magic. So what of the Accord? 

Monday, 21 March 2011

Driven #25:- C63 AMG vs C350CD


The Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG and its less expensive, less specialist little brother, the diesel fuelled C350 CDi Sport live at different reaches of the same price-list. They're salt and pepper, coffee and cream, scotch and soda. One loud and rambunctious, one coldly efficient. Or are they?

My major driving task for today saw me spending serious miles in both cars, looking for some kind of verdict, I didn't quite know what. After a day in two black leather saddles, what had I learnt?

Monday, 14 February 2011

Driven #21:- Jaguar S-Type :- Unexplained Attraction


Flaming Hot Monster Munch. Never liked ‘em. I didn’t really like any spicy food much, to be honest, and yet now if a peppered steak appears on the menu I’ll jump right at it, and the nice, gentle Roast Beef Monster Munch no longer hits the spot.

It’s funny how we suddenly take a liking to a taste, a sensation or a product that we previously held with disinterest or contempt. It happens with music, it happens with fashion, and it happens with cars. And yesterday evening, it happened to me with the Jaguar S-Type.

Monday, 7 February 2011

Driven #19:- E65 BMW 730d


It’s funny how things change. Last time I drove an E65 7 Series it had belonged to my boss. This was going back a few years, it was a facelifted, 2006 ½ machine, in Sterling grey, and I absolutely loved it. Such was its imperious bulk, traffic would part the instant it appeared in its rear view mirror, it made you feel special, very special indeed. Everything about it seemed designed to remind you that you had gained admission to the BMW executive lounge. You had made it in life.

It’s now, with the benefit of hindsight, that I realise I had probably been brainwashed by the great Munich corporate propaganda machine that I was working for at the time. Now's a good time for a re-evaluation - for here on my desk are the keys to an original, 2004 E65 730d. 

Tuesday, 1 February 2011

Driven #18:- 335d SE


The turbocharged, go-faster Volvo 850T-5 caused something of a stir on its release in the early nineties. For a start, it was a Volvo, and Volvo were more associated with ever-so-sensible brick shaped cars best suited for carrying elderly people and antiques. Then there was the power, the modernity, the fact that the car represented totally new ground for the staid old firm. Then, in ’94, Volvo took the 850 racing in the British Touring Car Championship. And, as if looking to take the piss totally, the combatant they fielded was an estate car.


Wednesday, 29 December 2010

The Old Versus The New. Again.


One of the most recognised Mercedes-Benz products is the G-Wagen, or Geländewagen, for cross-country vehicle. Herculean in its robustness and solidarity, it wears its exposed hinges on its sleeve and has continued in production for civilian use since 1979, with military variants being available before even then. Hardly changed externally in all those years, the Steyr-assembled vehicle has been given another lease of life and construction will continue into its fourth decade.

Thing is, as phenomenal a car as it is (and it really is), it’s just a bit hardcore for many. Like the Land Rover Defender, sturdy and heroic as it is, some people just want a little more luxury. And no matter how soft your leather is or how many buttons there are to press, luxury and brutality are uneasy bedfellows.

Tuesday, 21 December 2010

Driven #12:- Land Rover Freelander TD4 S


A recent trip around an all-terrain track in an open-top Defender reminded me just what Land Rover was all about. These were cars which could take on anything the world could throw at them, that would still be serviceable long after the cockroaches surrendered and even the Peugeot 504s had bitten the dust. 

Monday, 6 December 2010

Mass hysteria: Mercedes R350 CDi


A long while ago, I made a Roadwork entry on the re-styled Mercedes R-Class. I bemoaned the fact that the crazy, bug eyed visage of old had been dismissed, and a more conventionally attractive yet disappointingly bland face employed. I also mentioned that it's a car that also used to be unexpectedly fabulous car to drive.

And today I'm going to do exactly the same thing again.

Last weekend, after a hundred-mile dash to Gatwick Airport to help my hideously wealthy boss on his way to the Maldives, the R was as good as mine. My CDs in the stereo, seat electrically adjusted and climatically controlled to meet my exacting requirements. 


With His Nibs and entourage on board, the first part of the journey would be a sober, restrained, ministerial affair, and the R did a superb job of delivering my human cargo to its destination in an unruffled, efficient manner. I had four passengers on board and a hefty stack of luggage; in five-seat mode the load area made light work of swallowing a fortnight's worth of Gucci Bermuda shorts, Yves Saint Laurent thong bikinis, dress tiaras and sundry other holiday paraphernalia of the nouveau riche.

Despite this mountain of freight, the passengers still had their seats in their rearmost positions for maximised middle-row legroom. The young lady of the group was travelling in the least comfort, her seat being in the middle and somewhat compromised, compared with the throne-like outer perches. Still, there is lateral room enough for three people to travel abreast without developing homicidal tendencies.


After a journey free of drama, the Mercedes reached Gatwick Airport in what felt like double-quick time, and I hadn't even been misbehaving at the wheel. I disgorged the contents of the R-Class, human and otherwise and watched, sighing as they collectively buggered off to the tropics. I took comfort, though, in my subservience having been valuable in a research capacity; I had established that the R-Class is very good indeed at carrying people and their stuff. Of course, this was just a prelude to the main event. Balls to the passengers, what about the driver?

I would refer you to the complete non-review of the R350 by Matt Hardigree of Jalopnik. In fact, go and read it now. Chortle, belly-laugh, admire the wit and metaphor. Then come back and read about how it drives, 'cos Matt didn't really seem interested. In the comments he later admits that “It isn't too bad to drive”, and he's part right. The truth is, the R-Class is awesome.

It cheats, really. There's no direct comparison to make. Sitting on the same mechanical underpinnings as the ML and GL SUVs, the R shares a feeling of go-anywhere, do-anything. However, an R might have the same engine and transmission, but has nothing of the higher ground clearance, hill-descent control or differential lock that its taller stablemates employ on hostile terrain. Retaining permanent four-wheel drive, though, and this being teamed with road-biased tyres, what it does have is grip. Lots and lots of grip. On tarmac or concrete, in rain or snow - it hangs onto whatever you throw at it.


And grunt, too. This particular example is the R350 CDi, powered by a diesel engine that feels far more muscular than its three-litre capacity would suggest. It weighs in at 265bhp, which is quite a big number in itself, but it also has 620NM of torque, and it's this latter figure that has me doing very immature things on the motorway. Put simply, the novelty of pulling alongside something in such a leviathan, and then flooring it and disappearing towards the horizon with seemingly exponential acceleration just never wears off. It's magical, and I'm seriously surprised that Jalopnik Matt never noticed it.

This would be one hell of a machine in which to conquer continents. Endless shove and a surreal Orient-Express ride quality at motorway speeds. Best of all is the presence it has in the rear-view mirrors of lesser vehicles. People just yield, unquestioningly, although the shock-and-awe of the Xenon laser-death-beam headlamps and look-at-me LED running lights is probably partly responsible. 


Cruising at quasi-legal speeds as if it were second nature for the R-Class, I imagined the aesthetic that the car presented as it passed slower traffic. In a dark colour, with privacy glass, a fast-moving R-Class is undoubtedly a sinister looking machine. One might imagine some Government rapid-response special ops team to be lurking on board, speeding to intercept a secret shipment of classified materials at a darkened aerodrome somewhere, far from the likely reality of it containing the Wilkins family returning from a skiing trip to Val Disere.

I even enjoy the noise it makes. Diesel engines can never match the sonorous howl of a flat-plane petrol V8, or the crisp scream of a straight-six. At worst they are agricultural, a constant death-rattle redolent of imminent big-end failure; the best thing you can say of most of the better diesels is that they are nicely muted, usually being shrouded with heavy duty sound deadening materials. The V6 unit in the R350 CDi, though, is the best-sounding diesel I have ever sat behind.

For the most part it just provides a reassuring background hum, at high motorway speeds  it's not dissimilar to the sound in the cabin of a long-haul airliner, only quieter. Telegraph a demanding message to the engine-room, though, and the R-Class responds with a deep bellow that is the sound of pure industrial power.

Nought to sixty takes 7.7 second in this two ton monster, but the figures only tell a fraction of the story. Fact is, it goes like a stabbed rat. The deep well of torque, the, responsiveness of the gearbox and that 4x4 traction colaborate to make the R350 a devastatingly accomplished overtaker, and one whose firepower can be further massaged by those clever Brabus folk if you so desire.

Numbers aside, I always feel a little disappointed when I dismount from the R and saddle up in something like an S-Class. The S, even with the same engine as the R, feels so normal. It's a big Mercedes saloon, everybody expects it to be fast. The R has that delicious element of surprise to it.

 
Personally, I'd rather have an R than an S, as you're probably gathering by now. It's cheaper, even more so if you opt for the less powerful, rear-wheel-drive, shorter wheelbase R300 CDi model, but the full-fat 350 CDi is the one to have. I just wish it felt a bit more like an S-Class inside. 

Architecturally it's fine; everything is in the right place. The materials are perfectly respectable too, it's well built and feels like it'll last in the same way as Mercedes products used to. It all feels very professional, it just really needs to look a little more special.

Frustratingly, they nearly managed it; the armrests and switch panels on the doors are covered with beautifully stitched Artico (AKA "pretend") Leather to match the seats, but this finish doesn't stretch quite as far as onto the adjoining dashboard. It's such a shame; the plastics are nice, but a little bit everyday to be at home in such a unique car. 

 
Mercedes needs to have a better look at how it markets the R-Class; at the moment they haven't really assigned any particular image to it. Get some as VIP cars for film premiers instead of the usual raft of S-Classes. Add a little luxe to some of the more visible interior surfaces and it  suddenly becomes an entirely new kind of limousine. I mean, it's now far less polarising to look at now than it was; by the end of my weekend I had found several angles from which the R350 honestly looks very tasty indeed. Appealing enough, even, for me to cease defending the previous, facially disfigured R-Class. Yes, it used to stand out from the crowd, but I'll admit that this was for all the wrong reasons.

I look forward to using the R to collect my freshly tanned VIPs from Gatwick in a fortnight... I'll do my utmost to avoid giving away how much fun I've been having in the meantime.


Monday, 22 November 2010

Driven #8:- Mk 3 Mondeo 2.2 TDci

 
In 1997 Grand Theft Auto was released in all its anarchic, top-down glory. Here was a game where you were encouraged to steal any and all vehicles found prowling the mean streets of Liberty City. The choice was huge, with public utility vehicles like ambulances, coaches and police cars, as well as motorbikes and supercars. Some of these were recognisable. The Ferrari Testarossa made an appearance, as did the Escort Cosworth, both iconic machines. You could understand their inclusion.

One car, though, stood out to me. Why have they included that? Also, why have they awarded it such an insulting in-game name? That car was the Ford Mondeo. And that name? Mundano. And a new cliché was born.